Reaction to New York Times news on Afrin: Carlotta Gall does not reflect the truth

  • actual
  • 14:00 24 February 2021
  • |
img

ANKARA - Reacting to the article in the New York Times called "In Turkey’s Safe Zone in Syria, Security and Misery Go Hand in Hand", written by NYT's İstanbul reporter Carlotta Gall, Afrin Post stated that the article did not reflect the truth and Gall was trying to whitewash the invasion.

Reactions kept coming from the Kurds against the Carlotta Gall article published in New Yort Times on February 16. Following the developments in North and East Syria, Afrin Post told that the NYT was manipulating the truth and used Governor Orhan Aktürk appointed by Turkey to Syrian territory as a source as well as a Salafi jihadist as a' rebel fighter'. The article written by Gall was praised by Anadolu Agency (AA) which is under the control of the government.
 
The article Afrin Post published as a response to New York Times is as follows: 
 
"In its issue of February 16, 2021, The New York Times published a report on the current situation of Afrin; this article was entitled “In Turkey’s Safe Zone in Syria, Security and Misery Go Hand in Hand,” by Carlotta Gal, the director of the Istanbul office.
 
We, the Afrin Post, closely follow the details of what is happening in occupied Afrin, and we publish the news and reports in three languages ​, Kurdish, Arabic, and English.
 
With regret, we read the article published by your newspaper, and we found it full of errors, contradictions and were astonished to see only a single viewpoint, that of the Turkish government.
 
Gal’s title implies that Afrin is made safe because of the Turkish occupation. It is clear that from the outset, the author intends to beautify the Turkish invasion and occupation. The article is so one-sided that the tone is more akin to the Turkish Anadolu Agency, not something found in such a revered publication as the New York Times.
 
GALL'S REPORT DOES NOT REFLECT THE TURTH
 
The Times is known all over the world for its high degree of journalistic professionalism and objectivity. Publishing an article like Ms. Gal’s undermines the credibility that the paper has built upon for so many years; this is why we seek to clarify specific facts and address those Gal’s report ignored.
 
After the Turkish invasion and occupation, it is well known that the area was closed to the media. The occupying authorities do not allow entry by any media members, except when those journalists ensure that any reports will be favorable to the occupiers. It is also well documented that the people of Afrin, the original Kurds, are afraid to speak to the media.
 
Gal’s article does not reflect the reality of life in Afrin today. The report exaggerated sympathy for those forcibly deported people from eastern Ghouta to Afrin. The article does not say who fled because of the war, or because of the Turkish invasion. What happened to the owners of those homes? How did they leave their homes, fields, and graves of their families? The article does not say that the people were uprooted by force, nor where they live today.
 
We want to know precisely how the Turkish government can achieve “Turkish national security” by displacing people from homes and farms? Why are the people of Afrin not allowed to return?
 
To be clear, there are “new settlers” to Afrin. Those who moved into Afrin are armed militia members who are well-known for war crimes, robbed food aid from warehouses meant for refugees. The crisis which these criminals wrought transferred to Afrin with their arrival, a small part of a more dubious Russian-Turkish political agreement.
 
Since the invasion, many internationally accredited organizations have reported horrific accounts of human rights violations against Afrin citizens. Groups like the International Human Rights Organization, the International Investigation Committee on Syria, the American Religious Freedom Committee, the Egyptian Human Rights Foundation, and the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights. These groups have hundreds of accounts of war crimes, crimes against humanity, but Gal’s report mentioned none.
 
The militias that occupy Afrin have extremist political and religious ideologies; they have committed acts of genocide against the region’s Yazidis, including forced conversion to Islam, demolition of sacred shrines, and the widespread desecration of cemeteries with bulldozers. These occupiers seek to remove all traces of the rightful inhabitants.
 
To understand the reality of Afrin today, it is necessary to know what was the reality before the Turkish and Islamic militant invasion. The people of Afrin have a long tradition of not differentiating Syrians based on an ethnic, religious, or political basis. In short, Afrin was a haven for displaced Syrians.
 
This is the reality of aggressive Turkish posturing:
 
- Displaced Kurdish residents of Afrin number more than 300,000
- Islamist militias seized land and homes of the Kurdish people of Afrin; deportees, militia members were set up in their place
 
- Demographics changed as a direct result, Kurdish people, 97% of Afrin residents before the invasion now only represent 20% of the population
 
- Thousands of Kurdish citizens were arrested, kidnapped, and tortured in make-shift Islamic prisons throughout the region
 
- Dozens of Kurds have died from their experiences, and a more significant but still uncertain number remain missing
 
- Approximately 150,000 currently live in camps or the wrecks of homes destroyed by Turkish army bombardment
 
- The Turkish army continues to bomb the area of al-Shahba, and have massacred or displaced those people as well
 
Ankara justifies the war on Afrin under the pretext of Turkish national security, but what is the justification for the occupation and violations of human rights?
 
WHY WAS THE FORESTS BURNED DOWN?
 
Afrin is rich in olive trees – why have these trees been uprooted, forests burned?
 
Other non-human casualties are the UNESCO sites. These places are registered with UNESCO because they are part of our collective human heritage. Militia groups that occupy the region have attacked archaeologists, and the sites themselves, bulldozing and destroying many. These sites must be protected for all to enjoy and study.
 
Also included in Gal’s fiction is the narrative of the five million people of Idlib. The number is clearly wrong because the city would not be able to tolerate such a population. Because of the civil war, Idlib residents mostly fled to Afrin, but many others crossed the border to Turkey, or went on to Europe. The Syrian government regained much of the territory in and around Idlib at the beginning of 2020. After Assad’s reoccupation, Idlib became home to thousands of militants, many of whom are members of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (Jabhat al-Nusra), and al-Qaeda, well-known terrorist organizations. Groups like these are not Idlib’s people and should not be counted as such. These militants arrived through Turkish border crossings with the intent to establish emirates in Idlib.
 
Concerning the specifics of population, with 3.6 million Syrian refugees hosted by Erdogan in Turkey, the total for Idlib would be 8.6 million. A population of this number cannot be taken seriously. Idlib’s actual population, 1.68 million, represents only 7% of Syria’s total population, which only totals about 24 million, smaller overall numbers ten years into the civil war.
 
Another clarification is that Turkey did not fight ISIS in Syria. For example, on August 24, 2016, in Jarablus, the Kurds were fighting alongside the international coalition; within a few hours, hundreds of ISIS militants fled to Turkey and joined the National Army. Many of those militants have been seen in Afrin, and Ras al-Ain, another Syrian border city occupied by Turkey.
 
The truth of Ankara’s agenda is contrary to their statements in the media. In the years before the occupation of Afrin by Turkish forces, the area was safe and stable, despite the civil war that raged in other parts of Syria. It was only after Afrin fell to Turkey that the bombings began, directly resulting from factional fighting, specifically militants fighting militants. These skirmishes have made Afrin a battlefield.
 
We cannot and will not ignore the displacement camps. There are many painful stories from these camps, including high prices for goods, extreme poverty, and oppressive temperatures. There are many other more horrific stories about human rights violations, murders, dumping of corpses in the open, kidnapping, ransom collecting, and the mass rape of women.
 
THE INVASION IN AFRIN CAN NOT BE JUSTIFIED
 
Who authorizes these armed groups to commit all these violations?
 
Turkish officials might claim that their goal is to establish normalcy, but the reality is far from that. Afrin had a peaceful existence before the Turkish occupation, but no longer. Normal life is the return of its people to their land and homes. Normal is not the Islamic militants committing violent acts against residents. The occupation of Afrin must not be glossed over, and it cannot be justified.
 
As the occupying power, Ankara is directly responsible. Still, it is incumbent upon journalists and those who know the truth to report the facts as they are, not manipulate the information to suit politicians in Ankara.
 
The occupied area of Afrin is far from safe, for many more reasons than can be listed in a single article.
 
We hope that a large and influential media organization with a global reputation such as The New York Times will adopt more accurate reports or relegate articles as Gal’s to the Opinion section. We thank you for your cooperation and time to hear our viewpoint."

View More Articles

13/03/2021
10:42 Newroz with photographs
09:41 Hunger strike action enters day 108
12/03/2021
13:31 Prison administration returns March 8 postcards to senders
13:19 Kars Co-Mayor to remain in prison
13:15 Families ıf İmralı prisoners apply to be granted visit to Imrali
13:10 Police in Van close off street where HDP Provincial building is located
13:03 Hunger strike action in prisons enters day 106
11/03/2021
17:04 Women accused of 'jumping' at the March 8 rally were strip searched
17:03 Thousands march in Shengal
12:58 Women detained for participating in March 8 rally accused of 'jumping'
12:57 5 detained during raids on their homes in Malatya and Urfa
12:56 Lawyers of Öcalan submit new application to visit their client
11:08 Women detained last night with raids on their homes to be brought to court
11:07 Journalist Babaoğlu never came back from Siverek where he was following up a story for the last 27 years
11:07 On trial for speaking at her daughters funeral
09:39 Hunger strike action in prisons enters day 105
09:37 Women participated in March 8 rally detained
09:36 Burke from Unite the Union: Europe's silence against isolation is a disgrace
08/03/2021
16:53 European parliamentarians launch campaign for Demirtaş's freedom
16:44 Revolutionary Party Vice Chairperson ends home arrest on her own will for March 8
13:48 Court finds ministry culpable for 12-year-old Ceylan Önkol's death, orders compensation
11:12 Mesopotamia Women Journalists Platform: We are here, we are together
11:12 Inspector appointed to investigate if 3 crescent tattoo on perpetrator's hand was exposed deliberately
09:24 Hunger strike in prisons enters day 102
09:22 Witness of last March 8 women took to streets without hijabs in Iran
05/03/2021
18:15 Ministry of Justice: You can not ask questions about isolation
13:23 Hrant Dink murder case: Final hearing adjourned
13:17 Two more arrested as a result of operations against MEBYA-DER
13:12 Police blockade on all roads leading to HDP Van building
09:54 Hunger strike action in prisons enters day 99
04/03/2021
15:14 Two hearings of Özgür Gündem newspaper adjourned
14:32 Mayor of Yüksekova sentenced to seven years in prison
12:30 Application of the lawyers to visit İmralı rejected
12:29 February report from DFG: 26 years prison sentence for 6 journalists
10:57 Dündar accused of organizing protest while he was in prison
10:50 Investigation against HDP for revealing surveillence video instead of the police driving armored vehicles on children
10:50 Hunger strike in prisons enters day 98
10:26 Was Akbaşlı, claimed to has committed suicide mu
10:25 Prisoners beaten after Garé operation
10:24 March 8 preperations in Shengal, reborn from its ashes
03/03/2021
15:23 Sexual assault of police officer covered up
14:26 Content in Kobané summary goes back to 10 years
13:07 Application of the lawyers to visit İmralı rejected
12:57 8 women from 8 countries: We will succeed together
12:56 Second operation against MEBYA-DER: 81 year old executive detained
10:16 Hunger strike action in prisons enters day 97
02/03/2021
17:07 HDP MP Feleknas Uca's arm broken by police as new charges brough
17:03 Supreme Court launched an investigation against HDP
12:52 Attorneys of Öcalan submit application for İmralı
10:59 20th group takes over the hunger strike