Historian Dinç: Opening Hagia Sophia for worship on 'July 24' means something

img

İSTANBUL - Indicating that opening Hagia Sophia on the anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne means something rather than an arbitrary choice of date, historian and author Namik Kemal Dinc said, "Turkey declared that it evolves into an Islamic state."

The Council of State, Turkey's highest administrative court, on Friday unanimously revoked a 1934 cabinet decision making it a museum. Justice and Development Party (AKP) leader and President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said following the decision that the city’s sixth-century Hagia Sophia, which became a symbol of secularism in modern Turkey when it was converted into a museum in the 1930s, would reopen to Muslim prayer as a full-fledged mosque later this month. "God willing, we will perform Friday prayers all together on July 24 and reopen Hagia Sophia to worship," Erdogan said in an address to the nation.
 
Historian and author Namık Kemal Dinç shared his evaluations on Turkey's decision to change the status of Istanbul's landmark Hagia Sophia from a museum to a mosque.
 
BEFORE LAUSANNE- AFTER LAUSANNE
 
Stating that the Treaty of Lausanne signed on July 24, 1923 is important in terms of protecting the rights of minorities, but despite the agreement Turkey has not been protecting the rights of the minorities Dinç said, "After Lausanne, the policies have excluded non-Muslims, decreased non-Mulims population and substituted Muslim-Turkish population for their place. If you analyze the period after Lausanne, it will be seen that there is a decrease in both the number of places of worship for non-Muslims and the number of properties that belong to non-Muslims. Greeks had to migrate by force in 1960s as well as the Armenians who could not hold on to these lands and migrated."
 
'A POLITICAL DECISION'
 
Dinç evaluated the decision of the Council of State to open Hagia Sophia for worship as a "political decision". Stating that the judiciary has become an instrument of political power, Dinç said, “The (Turkish) government is trying to legitimize these decisions by the hands of judiciary."
 
'HAGIA SOPHIA IS SYMBOLIC'
 
"There are discourses symbolized by the sentences: 'We will build a mosque in Taksim, we will open Hagia Sophia for worship'. These things have been repeated over and over again since ancient times in the political history of Turkey. The AKP government brings these discourses back to life," said Dinç as the thinks that the Islamic movement in Turkey has built its rhetoric based on a "symbolic discourse". "It is very meaningful," noted Dinç saying, "While Atatürk Cultural Center (AKM) was falling down, Taksim Mosque was rising right in front of it. This is a symbolic message. It is the practice of many years of Islamic discourse. Hagia Sophia has such a symbolic character in this sense."
 
'JULY 24 GIVES A MESSSAGE TO THE WEST'
 
Dinç pointed out that Turkey's decision on opening Hagia Sophia for worship on July 24 that is the anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne means something. "There is no old Turkey anymore, that is the new Turkey," is the message that Turkey sends to the West by this choice of Date, according to Dinç who said, "Turkey says to the West 'We change the Kemalist understanding of history, we make a brand new reading of history.' There was an ideal in the Kemalist understanding of history, such as rising to the level of contemporary civilizations. Turkey says that these ideals are completely removed. This is a message that the old understanding of conquer has been revived to build a new Turkey."
 
'TURKEY ANNOUNCES A NEW STRUCTURE OF ISLAMIC STATE'
 
"The decision should not only be evaluated in terms of the Treaty of Lousanne, but also in terms of the manifestation of Turkey to reveal the difference between the old and the new Turkey," said Dinç. Mentioning the recent expansionist policies of Turkey in the Middle East and Libya. Dinç finished his evaluations with the following commends, "Turkey announces that it has evolved into an Islamic state structure. In this sense, this decision regarding Hagia Sophia, known as the symbol of peace, fellowship and tolerance should also be read as an attitude towards the Christian-Western world. In other words, it is declared that the Ottoman dreams have been re-aroused and Turkey will act accordingly."

View More Articles

12/07/2020
14:28 Historian Dinç: Opening Hagia Sophia for worship on 'July 24' means something
13:20 Earthquake in Georgia
12:51 4 prosecutors not investigate the perpetrators, but terrorize the killed family
11:50 Attack on largest Russian airbase in Latakia
10:50 Hagia Sophia: Letter from World Council of Churches to Turkey
10/07/2020
17:58 Lawyers pass the police baricades, march to the parliament
17:32 Sent to prison with her 10-month-old baby
17:11 Hunger strike to Didem Akman who has been on death fast
16:51 Lawyers not allowed in Kuğulu Park
16:50 Restriction to detainees to access lawyers
16:49 İmralı isolation is on the agenda of the parliament
16:49 Bar heads continued their vigil on benches
14:40 Raids and detentions in Adana and Mersin
09/07/2020
18:19 Police blockade on bar heads continue, lawyers are not allowed to join them
17:55 Hrant Dink trial posponed: Rejection to summon the intelliengence to the court
16:59 Demand for justice for the Kurdish journalist Aziz Oruç
16:30 Bar heads under police blockade in Ankara
16:30 HDP announces the schedule of "Democracy Meetings"
12:36 Bar heads invite the lawyers to Ankara: We will be on duty
12:35 Lawyers file application to Prosecutor's Office to visit Öcalan
11:11 Kurdish politicians: All steps towards the national unity
11:10 Turkish Parliament passes the two articles of the much debated 'multiple bars' bill
08/07/2020
19:57 Online meeting for the freedom of Öcalan
19:34 Witnesses take the stand in Hrant Dink trial
18:22 Protest in Ankara Courthouse for lawyers on death fast
17:24 Controversial 'mass grave' trial referred to Constitutional Court
12:30 The door of the HDP member marked by 'Turkish flag'
12:30 Mortal shell and mine ready to explode found in Diyarbakır
07/07/2020
19:05 Journalist Demir's trial postponed
18:52 Buried in the same grave: Father died in massacre, son died in airstrike
18:29 Çetin arrested: My political activities have been legal and public
16:21 Rojbin Çetin sent to court for arrest
06/07/2020
19:22 Application for Demirtaş’s release denied
18:35 Batman Municipality Co-Mayor and councilors detained
14:59 Bar heads back to their provinces: Everything is just beginning
14:58 Second phase in HDP's struggle program: Democracy Meetings
12:10 Death toll rises to 11 as migrant boat sinks in Lake Van
12:09 Prisons and COVID-19: Ill prisoners on the edge of 'death'
09:54 Multiple bar system proposal accepted at the Parliamentary Justice Commission
05/07/2020
17:05 Another flood in Başkale
16:54 The death of the child deemed as 'lawful'
15:13 'The end of the day in Libya for Turkey'
14:32 Slaughter of trees in Cudi Mountains
12:37 Urfa Bar Association Head: We will keep on struggle until the draft bill is withdrawn
12:02 Hot conflict in Dûpişk Hill
10:54 In quest of the bones of their father
10:14 DTK Co-Chair Öztürk: Targeting DTK is an attack on the future of the peoples of Turkey
09:35 Comission passes 12 articles of the much debated bill to split bars
03/07/2020
19:24 Death toll in the fireworks factory explosion raised to 4
19:03 4 human rights activists convicted of terror charges